Where then does this leave handicrafts as a livelihood option for alleviating poverty?
DFID encourages the use of the sustainable livelihood framework for analysis and planning of development interventions. The following section discusses sustainable livelihoods in order to place the commentary on the specific subject of handicrafts and e-commerce linkages to handicrafts in context.
Three interviews with craft producers from HEED
Handicrafts (Bangladesh) and ASHA Handicrafts (India).[1]
HEED Handicrafts, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Kalachand Pal, 38, is a male potter from
Madhumpura, Patuyakhali, 300km from Dhaka. His father and grandfather were
both potters before him. He is married with one son (11) and produces pots
for both the local market, and for HEED Handicrafts for export.

Capital
|
Capital |
Description |
|
Human |
· He attended Primary School to class 7. · He has traditional skills as a potter making ceramic pots. · He says he is in good health. |
|
Physical |
· His village (Madhumpura) has electricity and water from a tubewell (though there is now a big problem and national scandal in Bangladesh with water contaminated by arsenic). He says it is a good place to live. · His father owns the plot of land for their house – but no land for a paddy field. Kalachand will inherit this with his two brothers on his father’s death. · He owns a manual potters wheel, bought 15 years ago (worth c 5,000 Takka c £60) |
|
Financial |
· He has savings (enough to sustain his family for one year) · He owns a cow (worth 10,000 Takka: c£125) for producing milk; plus with his brother owns 100 rain trees (kri), whose wood is used for building. · He has a workshop which can accommodate up to 100 workers (if he has many orders to fulfil) |
|
Social |
He has many customers for his pots: a wholesale buyer, individuals and HEED Handicrafts. |
Vulnerability context
|
Shock |
Occasional sickness. |
|
Trend |
Inheritance between brothers means that the family plot will be jointly owned after his father’s death. |
|
Seasonal |
Bangladesh suffers from seasonal flooding. |
|
Seasonal |
His local buyers are dependent on good harvests to create cash to buy his pots. So if the harvest is poor, as it has been for the last two years, his local sales are reduced. |
Policies, Institutions and Processes
|
Culture |
Corruption/bribery is widespread |
|
Structure |
Communications with Dhaka are difficult. Telephone system is poor and unreliable; post cannot be trusted. |
Livelihood Strategies
|
|
He is not dependent on just one buyer or market, so is confident he will also be able to sell his pots. |
|
|
He can take on additional part-time workers to cope with seasonal orders; and to cope with sudden larger orders from HEED Handicrafts |
|
|
He wants to make samples from his own designs (eg vases and decorative items) for both local and export markets |
|
|
He has not taught his son to be a potter. He wants his son to get a degree, so he can become a doctor or professional. He wants his son to have a better job than him. |
Livelihood Outcomes
|
|
Good harvest this year, so he is selling a good number of pots. |
|
HEED Handicrafts, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Saleh Khatung works as a spinner for HEED
Handicrafts in their workshop in Dhaka. She has two daughters, aged 20 and
14, who are both working. Her husband is a weaver too, and works for HEED,
though this is dependent on orders.
Capital
|
Capital |
Description |
|
Human |
· She has traditional spinning skills · She is in good health. |
|
Physical |
· She lives in a rented house in Dhaka. She has access to gas, water, electricity. |
|
Financial |
· Her husband owns a small plot of land in Norshindi village (150km away) – suitable for building a house (not big enough for a paddy field) |
|
Social |
· They work as a family. Her daughters also work for HEED in a different part of the workshop. |
Vulnerability context
|
Shock |
· She has a little sickness in her stomach sometimes. |
|
Trend |
· As the number of children increase, inherited land is divided, leading to land shortages. |
|
Seasonal |
· Work for both her and her husband is highly dependent on local/export orders of HEED Handicrafts. They had not worked for the previous three months. Her whole extended family is dependent on HEED. |
|
Trend |
· HEED Handicrafts is operating in a very competitive market place. |
|
Seasonal |
· Flooding affects their home, which was flooded in 1988 and 1998. |
Policies, Institutions and Processes
|
Culture |
· She (and her four sisters) were not sent to Primary School. They stayed at home, doing chores, spinning etc. |
|
Culture |
· Endemic corruption. |
Livelihood Strategies
|
|
· If they cannot find work, they will go back to their village, where it is cheap to live (no rent, no bills) |
|
|
· Her husband will do different work if he cannot work as a spinner – he has also worked as a packer for HEED Handicrafts. |
|
|
· She believes that if she cannot find work, her husband will find work for her. ‘That is his responsibility,’ she says. |
ASHA Handicrafts, Mumbai, India
